
By Roxanne Brown Concerned Neighbors of 320 Sunset (CNS)
At the prior West LA Planning Commission (WLAPC) hearing for Gjusta’s (320 Sunset) change of use from bakery/take out only to restaurant with full alcohol, commissioners were upset that Maya Zaitzevsky, Zoning Administrator, was not present. They insisted on her presence and the presence of Building and Safety.
At this appeal hearing on March 2,2016, Zaitzevsky was present. Building and Safety was not present.
ZAITZEVSKY PRO GJUSTA
Zaitzevsky started by stating that the past record can’t be looked at. Each case is presented individually: can’t presume Camaj will be a bad operator.
Regarding alcohol, Zaitzevsky stated, “Gjelina only seats people for an hour – not enough time to get drunk.” She further stated, “Their plans show more than I approved – 87 seats. I’m not sure if it’s accurate.”
Zaitzevsky said there had been so many plan changes, that’s why she marked them up so much – to make them more clear. Unfortunately, CNS had not seen the new plans, nor were they allowed to view them at the hearing.
With the new plans, cars will enter and exit on Sunset (rather than the alley). The parking lot will now hold seventeen cars (although CNS has never seen it hold more than eleven at present.
REZNIK OPENING REMARKS
Ben Reznik, attorney, presented that Fran Camaj’s Gjelina, GTA, and Gjusta have an exemplary record and Camaj is an upstanding member of the community.
Reznik stated that the patio will be enclosed. He said this will eliminate noise. The patio will have a retractable roof that let’s the sun in.
MAROSI OPENING REMARKS
Ilana Marosi, Appellant and President of Concerned Neighbors of 320 Sunset (CNS), presented the opposite case. She presented evidence showing hundreds of violations, nuisance complaints, and non-compliance issues at Fran Camaj’s Gjelina’s, GTA, Gjusta, and the Black Beast at 1305 Abbot Kinney.
HEALEY OPENING – VENICE CRIME DROPS WHEN ALCOHOL LICENSES RISE
Laurette Healey, consultant working with Reznik and Camaj, presented a chart that demonstrated her words, which were: Unlike other areas, adding a liquor license in Venice brings the crime rate down.
Healey stated that: “Crime exponentially went down as alcohol went up in Venice from 2009-2015.”
CNS REBUTTAL
A CNS member stated that the LA Times reports Venice crime up. Further, the LA Times reports that the LAPD has understated that crime rate.
Another CNS member cited evidence from Pacific Division: DUI’s in Venice from December 6, 2015 to January 2, 2016 were up 800%.
Sarah Blanch from the Public Policy Institute said: There is a point where alcohol licenses reach a critical mass – Venice is already saturated – and that is harming the public’s health and safety.
Dr. Todd Sherman representing the Renaissance building (70 units) on Main between Rose and Marine said that homeowners there have witnessed, “ With the increase in restaurants with alcohol, we have seen crime increase. Our Home Owners Association has hired its own security guard. Perhaps this is not on LAPD’s radar.”
HEALEY AND CNS REGARDING HOMELESS
Healey further stated that: We all know bringing a restaurant in reduces homeless and crime.
A CNS member later countered, “Since Gjusta’s arrival, the homeless population which used to be confined to 3rd has now spread further onto the 300 block of Sunset and beyond.”
APPLLEANT JIM MUREZ – PRO GJUSTA
Commission President Donovan stated that, “It’s a little strange to have an appellant in favor of the project.”
Murez, a former LUPC Chair, stated that he felt with the changed plans, Gjusta was an exceptionally brilliant solution to a troubled neighborhood.
CNS MEMBERS and RESIDENTS TESTIFY OPPOSING GJUSTA
A CNS member/resident who resides in the 300 block of Sunset stated that he sees Gjusta customers pee in the alley behind Gjusta and has seen a significant increase in critters – rats.
Reznik later said: The homeless pee in the alley. Not Gjusta’s customers.
CNS members cited everything you readers have heard before: disregard for rules, regulations, violations, nuisance, noise, traffic, and parking problems since Gjusta’s arrival.
GJUSTA EMPLOYEES, VENDORS, CUSTOMERS TESTIFY
A Gjusta customer stated: I no longer have to carry my stun gun when I walk in the 300 block of Sunset.
Gjusta employees and vendors complimented Camaj on being a great employer to work for and providing internships, jobs, and voluntary help in the community.
Dustin Mills a business owner behind Gjelina says he has had no issues with Gjelina.
PRESIDENT VENICE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
Carl Lambert, President of the Venice Chamber of Commerce sat on Gjusta’s side at the hearing. Lambert owns multiple apartment buildings that he converted into “de facto hotels.”
REZNIK CLOSING REMARKS PRO GJUSTA change of use from bakery
In closing, Reznik presented Camaj as a responsible alcohol licensee.
Reznik called CNS members Gjusta’s “aggressive neighbors.”
1. Reznik concluded that Gjusta would now be a restaurant, bakery, and retail with full alcohol – on site only (imposed by commissioners and agreed to – no off-site sales)
2. Gjusta patio will be enclosed with skylight and doors. Walls will be the appropriate 4-pound thickness, which is adequate according to the City’s Building & Safety engineers.
(Architect Stephen Vitalich said earlier that Gjusta’s patio walls will have 4 pounds of noise protection per square foot. CNS Sound Engineer and Acoustics’ Expert, Cambridge educated Kevin Madigan, testified that a sheet of drywall provides 40 pounds of protection.)
3 Gjusta will have a signed agreement with Board of Ed for valet parking.
4. Alcohol is part of an eating experience – no need for off-site.
Reznik and Murez stated: Everyone knows the Metro yard at Main and Sunset will be a parking lot providing 1,000 parking spaces.
MAROSI, PRESIDENT CNS, CLOSING – OPPOSING GJUSTA
Marosi stated, “ We are aggressive neighbors, because Building and Safety and the City don’t enforce conditions, code, rules, regulations – so we are driven to do so.”
Marosi stated that the fact is CNS has evidence, and there is evidence online, of Gjelina/GTA serving alcohol in what is supposed to be an upstairs apartment, and serving food and alcohol in the back alley patio area of GTA which has no permit to do so.
CNS Neighborhood Watch kept records of dates and times that Gjelina catering special events with food and alcohol in the “apartment:” more than 170 times in the past 1-½ years. Marosi concluded that this shows Camaj is not a reliable alcohol licensee and cannot be trusted to uphold conditions.
Marosi further concluded that business owner Camaj has a pattern and practice of bad behavior. He has shown himself to not be responsible with alcohol. Camaj continues to serve food and alcohol in an unpermitted event center “apartment” and in GTA’s patio/alley and back alley.
She showed 100 pages – 1 inch thick of violations and complaints and nuisance evidence, which are detrimental to the health and safety and welfare of the Venice Community. There is a clear pattern of abuse over the past eight years.
Marosi asked the commissioners to please uphold the appeal.
WLAPC DECISION
Commissioner President Thomas M. Donovan and Commissioners Lisa WaltzMorocco, Marian Merritt, Esther Margulies, and Joseph W. Halper approved change of use as outlined above in Reznik’s concluding remarks.
Throughout the hearing, Commissioner Halper did push for enclosed roof, enclosed patio, no off-site liquor, and did say he was very concerned about parking and the disturbance imposed on this neighborhood by Gjusta.
This hearing is audio and video recorded. CNS was there from 4:30 until 1 a.m.
ROCKY’S OPINION: CITIZENS WIN WHILE LOSING at GJUSTA APPEAL HEARING
CNS did achieve its goal: providing evidence of wrong doing and speaking the truth. Mayor Eric Garcetti, his administration, his City Council, and his WLAPC have now given the green light to more “property gangster” – some one that ignores laws.
Venetians are inspired to keep fighting for truth and justice. If you disagree with this approval, please contribute $5 now – this very moment – before you forget – to save Venice. These monies are and will be used to hire experts and lawyers -https://www.gofundme.com/helpsavevenice
It seems we no longer live in a democracy for the people by the people. We seem to be experiencing a dictatorship run by special interests with a puppet government.
VOTE MITCHELL SCHWARTZ to replace GARCETTI.