web analytics

Rss

Venice News Updates

News of Venice, CA and Marina del Rey CA

Scooters — Latest Concerns and Enforcement

By Darryl DuFay

Over the past months we have become aware of Electric Scooters.  The names: “Bird” and “Lime” were the first.  Now they have added:  “Jump” from Uber and “Spin” from Ford.  GM will come out with electric bicycles in 2019.

The sudden appearance of the vehicles caught all unprepared, and the companies  took advantage.  They had no permits to operate “dockless” scooters.  Geography made no difference to the spread of the scooters.  Santa Monica developed a program to deal with scooters. Beverly Hills and other cities just banned the  scooters.  Los Angeles at first seemed flustered and overwhelmed, especially in Venice.

So what is being done and what needs to be done. It will take time.  There is definitely a learning curve.

Permit Program: On Oct. 1, 2018, the City began a Permit Pilot Program to regulate “dockless bikes and scooters.”  The companies must have a Permit to operate. The permitting is in two parts.  First part is an application period lasting 120 days for conditional approval.  Then they may receive a permanent approval for one year.  The Program is planned to operate for one year after issuance of the first program permit. “Several companies have applied for permits and LADOT is currently reviewing those applications for consistency with the guidelines.”

The guiding documents are at the LADOT website: DOCKLESS ON-DEMAND PERSONAL MOBILITY RULES & GUIDELINES.

1.  Concerns — Known and Under Development

The biggest outcry has been about “scooters” driving up to 15 mph down their sidewalks.  Electric scooters are recognized in the CA Vehicle Code, Section 21235. The Los Angeles City Council is now taking action in conjunction with the Los Angeles Department of Transportation (LADOT), its Council’s Transportation Committee, chaired by Mike Bonin and other interested council members, and the LAPD.

An operator of a motorized scooter shall not, “Operate a motorized scooter upon a sidewalk, except as may be needed to enter or leave adjacent property.” CA Vehicle Code 21235, (g).  However, there is not yet a posted sign for electric scooters for that prohibition.  The City is working on that sign, which normally cites a Municipal Code. Without a sign a ticket or notice of infraction could be challenged. The companies are required to put “No riding on sidewalks” in a large font on the standing area of the scooter.

2.  Enforcement.  Who does what?  

Ticketing vehicles such as an electric scooter is the responsibility of the LAPD West Traffic Division.  These are the motorcycle people.  Mike Bonin’s office is “…in contact with LAPD about enforcement of the vehicle code sections that apply to scooters riders.”  There is a dire need of additional resources for them to be successful.  They are reviewing using funds from the program generated by fees the companies pay and to focus that money at high-impact areas.  Venice will surely qualify.  The community’s involvement is critical to the success of the program.  Calling the West Traffic Division to report moving violations creates a violation record which will be used to allocate where resources are needed.

Note: LAMC 63.44(O)  Venice Beach Parking Regulations, which has been successfully used to stop electric scooters use along Ocean Front Walk and the bike path is restricted  to  Santa Monica boundary south to Washington Blvd.

But what about when the scooters are not moving and are parking in an unsafe manner?  The City is building an app to dial 311 for scooter parking problems.  It should be available in January.  The City is also working with the companies on their “nesting” criteria.  Maybe a play on words from “Bird.”  It means where and how many scooters are placed in a location.  On Oct. 24, there were 50 scooters within one block of the corner of Windward and Pacific Ave.  This is where the community will be a great assistance in aiding enforcement by using the 311 app.

The City is relying heavily on the companies to enforce City Rules and Guidelines.  For example: Two hours to remove a scooter illegally parked.  Where to park at corners. Parking only in “landscape & furniture” zones, which is a fancy description of the area next to the curb where there is a wide sidewalk.  But, you cannot park on the landscape only on a hard surface like concrete.

… and now there is Spin

By Darryl DuFay

You can now add Spin to Bird, Lime, and Jump as the names of Electric Scooters and Bikes. Plans by Ford for massive expansion by 2020. Appears General Motors will also be getting into the business.

The City of LA is “great” in clouding the discussion of their new endeavors. Short-Term Rentals became “Home Sharing.” Electric scooters and bikes, which are being guided by the Department of Transportation (DOT) have become DOCKLESS ON-DEMAND PERSONAL MOBILITY vehicles.

Scooter CVC Rules of the Road

By Darryl DuFay

Venice LAPD personnel were notified two months ago about current CA Vehicle Codes (CVC), relating to electric scooters such as Bird and Lime.

Commanding Officer Captain James Roberts sent out a notice.
Electric scooters are a “moving” vehicle. Therefore, it is like a car or motorcycle. It falls under the jurisdiction of the LAPD West Traffic Division. When illegally parked they fall under the Department of Parking enforcement.

The LA City Council is also working on their own Rules and Regulations and implementations. However, the CVC supersedes the City Rules and Regulations where they may disagree.

The City can also decide how many scooters are allowed to be used and where and when. Where they can be parked. Also, what permits and costs of operating in the City, etc.

notice1notice2

Scooters Just Do Not Stop Making the News — Now They are Being Sued

Since the bird landed, stories have been abundant regarding the scooter and now the scooter companies –Lime and Bird have a class action suit against them for aiding and abetting assault.

Absolutely No Drinking and Scootering

scooters

By Darryl DuFay

LA has the first DUI conviction of a very drunk scooter rider.

There have been eight scooters in the Grand Canal by the tidal gates at Washington Blvd. They are polluting the water with their electric battery and greased wheel bearings. Dead fish found under them.

Councilman Mike Bonin views electric scooters as a mechanical marvel. He’s balancing on both sides of the issue. As to enforcement, “His office said he doesn’t do enforcement. Call the LAPD.” But be aware there is a difference in responsibilities.

The West Traffic Division only deals with moving vehicles such as cars, bikes, motorcycles, and electric scooters. They do not have the resources to do any significant enforcement. If it is not moving call the Department of Transportation for related issues such as parking problems. If you encounter an accident, call the LAPD and 911 for an ambulance.

The LA City Council is working on electric scooters. They have an over weight Dept. of Transportation Report. It goes back and forth from committee to committee and right now is supposed to be moving towards completion. First thing you should look for are significant resources for ENFORCEMENT. Proven past behaviors guarantee you won’t find any.

Scooters on Speedway at Washington

scooter
(Photo courtesy of Wolf Seeberg.)

Scooters lined up on Speedway at Washington Blvd.

Garbage collectors will be happy to see scooters surrounding bin.

Police Clip Birds’ Wings at Venice Beach and Ocean Front Walk

bird1
Parking yard off Venice Bike Path near Venice Beach Police Substation.

bird5
Shown from a different angle at beach to highlight the numbers.

bird2
Parking yard off Ocean Front Walk at Windward.

Police officers clipped the wings of the Birds Saturday and created two Bird Yards — one off the bike path at the Venice Beach near the police substation and the other off Ocean Front Walk at Windward.

Police operated from 10 am to 2 pm Saturday, according to Officer Mike Putrah, at the Venice bike path near the Venice police substation at Windward and at the Ocean Front Walk at Windward.

Five officers (Putrah, Lacunia, Passley, Moses, and Garciano) stopped the Lime and Bird scooter riders at the bike path near the Venice Police Substation from riding on the bike path. Two other officers (sorry, names were not recorded) were at the Ocean Front Walk stopping the scooter riders from operating on Ocean Front Walk.

Each officer courteously explained to scooter riders that one could not ride on the bike path or Ocean Front Walk. Officers also explained that with a helmet and a driver’s license, scooter riders could ride on the roadways.

Bird employee walks three Birds to SUV loading.

Bird employee walks three Birds to SUV loading.

The officers did not impound or confiscate the scooters, nor did they arrest drivers or give them a citation. They told them they could walk or carry their scooters to a proper area or they could leave them. Most left them. The police officers also notified both Lime and Bird officials that the scooters had been parked and that they could come and pick them up.

bird4

Can we fit this many in the SUV? There are over a hundred left just at OFW.

Law cited was LAMC 63.44(O)

63.44(O) (New Subsec. O. Added by Ord. No. 173,922, Eff. 5/28/01.)
Within the limit of any park consisting of beach lands or beach properties adjoining the waterfront of the Pacific Ocean between the southerly boundary of the City of Santa Monica and Washington Street in the City of Los Angeles:

1. No person shall operate a motorized scooter on any boardwalk, sidewalk, bike path or other public way. For the purpose of this subsection, the term “motorized scooter” shall mean any two-wheeled device that has handlebars, is designed to be stood or sat upon by the operator, and is powered by an electric motor that is capable of propelling the device with or without human propulsion, excluding motorcycles (as defined in Vehicle Code Section 400), motor-driven cycles (as defined in Vehicle Code Section 405),motorized bicycles or mopeds (as defined in Vehicle Code Section 406) and a toy (as defined in Health and Safety Code Section 108550). A device meeting the above definition that is powered by a source other than electrical power is also a motorized scooter

Scooters Banned in Beverly Hills

Beverly Hills has ban the Bird and the Lime scooters for six months. based on public safety.  They gave out tickets to riders for not having a valid driver’s license and/or helmet.

See LA Times story http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-scooters-beverly-hills-20180724-story.html

 

 

Scooter Legislation Is Coming for Venice, LA City

Scooters have taken Venice by storm.  They are here, there, everywhere.  Everyone has a story.  Almost everyone has ridden one. Almost all the local cities have enacted laws prohibiting them from the beach paths, sidewalks, and parks.  Los Angeles, which Venice is part of, is proposing legislation to regulate the scooters.

Pilot Program Elements

Safety– All vehicles will be required to adhere to California safety standards and submit a record of reported collisions on a monthly basis. We will also require bikes to have a tail light (CA law only requires headlights for bikes) and scooters to have a minimum 48-point font notice not to ride on sidewalks.

Operations and Maintenance– Operators must provide maintenance logs and have a staffed operations center with a 24-hour hotline.

Parking– Operators will be required to use technology that can tell if a device is upright. Operators are required to maintain a 24-hour hotline and respond to improperly parked or inoperable devices within 2 hours, from 7 AM to 10 PM daily. Not meeting this 2-hour standard subjects companies to having their permits revoked.

Fleet Size — Operators must have a minimum fleet size of 500 and maximum of 3,000 per company at launch. Companies may add an additional 2,500 devices in Disadvantaged Communities, and yet another additional 5,000 devices in Disadvantaged Communities in the San Fernando Valley. Thus, a company can launch with up to 10,500 devices if fully utilizing these incentives. After demonstrating compliance with program requirements and meeting certain performance criteria, LADOT will allow companies to increase their fleet size. The program does not specify a fleet size cap.

Fleet Composition– To make the system more accessible to people with a range of fitness and abilities, operators would be required to either make 50% of their bike fleets electric-assist or 1% of their fleets handicap-accessible.

Outreach and Equity– Companies are required to prepare an outreach plan that reflects local stakeholders in each community, including neighborhood councils, business districts, community organizations, and disability services providers. There are incentives built into the program to encourage companies to serve low-income communities. Operators must also provide a non-smart phone option for reservations, a cash payment option, reduced fares for low-income individuals, a multilingual mobile app, and a call center.

Data Sharing– LADOT is proposing a new data standard for the industry so that we know what is going on and can make smart management decisions.

Permit Pricing Fees– $20,000 for the annual permit, $130 per vehicle, $39 per vehicle in disadvantaged community, $28.32/hr for the removal/relocation of scooters; and $80/bicycle performance bond.

Enforcement and Evaluation– LADOT will use data collected from the pilot to evaluate operators and enforce permit conditions. If an operator is not responsive, LADOT will partner with the Bureau of Sanitation to remove improperly parked or inoperable devices from the public right-of-way.

Santa Monica Stops Scooters and Venice Becomes Parking Place

By Noel Johnston

1
Friday Santa Monica put out the sign that says “No Electric Scooter Zone. It’s the Law. The lower two lines say “Motorized Scooters Are Prohibited on Santa Monica Beach Bike Path, Sidewalks, and Parks.” The sign was posted on the bike path heading north into Santa Monica from Venice.

2
Sunday … Parking lot for scooters on the Venice side, partly on the right of way and partly on private property.

3
This needs to be addressed. It is a mess and an eyesore.